Economic and Budget Outlook, Winter 2023

1. Summary

This Economic and Budget Outlook report provides the FAO’s projection of the Ontario government’s fiscal position over the 2022-23 to 2026-27 period. The report also compares the FAO’s budget outlook to the government’s plan presented in the 2022 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review (Fall Economic Statement, or FES) from 2022-23 to 2024-25 and describes the FAO’s updated economic outlook. The FAO’s revenue and program spending projections are based on current and announced government policies.

Ontario’s economic growth to slow sharply

Ontario’s economy rebounded rapidly from the pandemic, with real GDP rising strongly by 5.2 per cent in 2021 and an estimated 3.7 per cent in 2022. However, facing elevated inflation, high interest rates and a weaker global environment, Ontario’s economic growth is projected to slow sharply to 0.5 per cent in 2023, and then return to close to historical averages over the rest of the outlook.

Budget improvements lead to growing surpluses

The FAO projects a budget deficit of $2.5 billion in 2022-23, significantly smaller than the government’s deficit projection of $12.9 billion in the FES. This $10.4 billion difference results mainly from the FAO’s lower spending projection, combined with a modestly higher revenue projection in that year. With revenue growth projected to exceed program spending growth over the outlook, the FAO projects a budget surplus of $1.0 billion in 2023-24 growing to $7.6 billion in 2026-27. The government projects improving deficits over its three-year outlook.

Revenue growth to moderate after historic gain

After total revenues grew by an exceptional 12.2 per cent in 2021-22, revenue growth is projected to moderate to 3.6 per cent per year over the outlook, in line with the slowing economy. Compared to the FES, the FAO’s revenue forecast is $1.7 billion higher in 2022-23, narrowing to $0.7 billion higher by 2024-25.

Program spending outlook below government forecast

Compared to the government’s three-year program spending projection in the FES, the FAO’s program spending projection is lower in each year. The FAO expects that spending on programs will be $6.8 billion lower than planned by the Province in 2022-23, narrowing to $4.5 billion lower in 2023-24, and $1.2 billion lower in 2024-25. In total, over the three-year period, the FAO projects that the Province has allocated a cumulative $12.5 billion in excess funds that are not currently required to support existing programs and announced commitments.

Although the FAO projects that the Province has allocated $12.5 billion in excess funds, differences arise by program sector. Notably, the FAO projects spending shortfalls in health (net $5.0 billion over three years), education ($1.1 billion) and justice ($0.8 billion). These shortfalls mean that the Province has not allocated sufficient funds to these sectors to support existing programs and announced commitments.

On the other hand, the Province has allocated excess funds to ‘other programs’ (net $19.7 billion over three years). The significant excess funds in the other programs sector are largely due to the contingency fund, which is excluded from the FAO’s projection as the purpose of the funds has not yet been announced.

2. Budget and Debt Outlook

FAO projects growing budget surpluses

Following a budget surplus of $2.1 billion in 2021-22,[1] the FAO projects that Ontario will post a $2.5 billion deficit in 2022-23 under current government policies.[2] The FAO expects improving budget surpluses over the outlook, growing from $1.0 billion in 2023-24 to $7.6 billion in 2026-27.

The FAO’s deficit projection of $2.5 billion in 2022-23 is considerably lower than the government's $12.9 billion deficit projection in the 2022 Fall Economic Statement. This $10.4 billion lower projected budget deficit compared to the government’s is comprised of:

• $6.8 billion lower projected program spending than in the government’s plan, due in part to the FAO’s exclusion of the government’s significant contingency funds as the purpose of the funds has not yet been announced;
• $1.7 billion higher revenue;
• $0.9 billion lower debt-interest payments; and
• the exclusion of the government’s $1.0 billion budget reserve.

By 2024-25, the last year of the FES outlook, the government projects a $0.7 billion deficit. In contrast, the FAO expects Ontario to record a surplus of $4.2 billion.

Figure 2.1: FAO expects growing budget surpluses after 2022-23

Note: The budget balance from the 2022 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review is shown after the reserve.

Source: Ontario Public Accounts, 2022 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review and FAO

Accessible version

However, if the government makes future announcements, such as new tax cuts, spending initiatives or a combination of both, the FAO’s budget projection would deteriorate. The FAO’s economic and budget outlook also faces significant external risks – see Chapter 6 for a discussion.

Budget surpluses would improve Ontario’s fiscal sustainability indicators

The Province’s net debt-to-GDP ratio is projected to decline from 39.2 per cent in 2021-22 to 36.3 per cent by 2024-25, which is 2.0 percentage points below the government’s projection in the FES. As the economy grows faster than the increase in debt, the FAO expects the net debt-to-GDP ratio to decline to 34.1 per cent by 2026-27 – the lowest ratio since 2010-11 and well below the government’s medium-term target of 42 per cent.[3]

Ontario’s debt interest payments as a share of revenues are projected to decline from 6.8 per cent in 2021-22 to 6.6 per cent in 2024-25, below the government’s projection of 7.3 per cent. By 2026-27, the ratio is projected to fall to 6.3 per cent – the lowest share on record going back to the early 1980s. Despite higher interest rates,[4] the projection for interest on debt as a share of revenues is expected to remain below the government’s target of eight per cent[5] in the medium term.

Figure 2.2: Ontario’s fiscal sustainability indicators to improve and remain below government targets

Source: Ontario Public Accounts, Ontario Economic Accounts, 2022 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review and FAO.

Accessible version

3. Revenue Outlook

FAO projects weak revenue growth in 2022-23 and 2023-24

In 2021-22, revenues jumped by 12.2 per cent (+$20.2 billion), driven by historically strong growth in tax revenues, which reflected the rebound in economic activity as employment growth and rising inflation pushed up labour income, consumer spending and corporate profits.[6] This revenue gain was more than four times the average annual increase from 2011-12 to 2019-20.[7]

Despite strong economic growth and high inflation in 2022, total revenue growth is projected to slow to 1.9 per cent (+$3.5 billion) in 2022-23, reflecting the loss of one-time revenue, declines in housing market activity, the reduction in the Gasoline and Fuel Tax, and the enhanced Low-income Individuals and Families Tax (LIFT) Credit. Modest revenue growth is projected to continue in 2023-24 (3.3 per cent or +$6.2 billion) as economic growth weakens, moderating labour income gains and sharply slowing corporate profit growth. Over the entire outlook, total revenues are projected to grow by an average annual rate of 3.6 per cent as economic activity begins to recover in 2024.

FAO’s revenue projection is modestly higher than the government’s

The FAO’s revenue projection is moderately above the government’s outlook in the 2022 Fall Economic Statement in each year. The FAO expects total revenues to be $1.7 billion higher than the government’s forecast in 2022-23 and 2023-24, and $0.7 billion higher in 2024-25. The difference between the FAO’s projection over the three-year period and the government’s is largely due to the FAO’s slightly stronger outlook for tax revenues and the FAO's inclusion of equalization payments to Ontario.[8]

Figure 3.1: Revenue growth to weaken after post-pandemic surge

Source: Ontario Public Accounts, 2022 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review and FAO

Accessible version

The FAO’s revenue outlook is consistent with the economic outlook in Chapter 5, which projects a significant slowdown for Ontario’s economy in 2023. However, numerous risks exist to the economic outlook that could negatively impact future revenue growth. These risks are discussed in Chapter 6.

4. Program Spending Outlook

FAO’s program spending projection is lower than the government’s

The FAO projects that the Province will spend $178.3 billion on programs in 2022-23, an increase of $7.9 billion (4.6 per cent) from the previous year. By 2026-27, the FAO projects program spending will reach $199.4 billion, with an average annual growth rate of 3.2 per cent over the five-year period.[9]

Compared to the government’s three-year program spending projection in the 2022 Fall Economic Statement, the FAO’s program spending projection is lower in each year. The FAO expects that spending on programs will be $6.8 billion lower than planned by the Province in 2022-23, narrowing to $4.5 billion lower in 2023-24, and $1.2 billion lower in 2024-25. In total, over the three-year period, the FAO projects that the Province has allocated a cumulative $12.5 billion in excess funds that are not currently required to support existing programs and announced commitments.

Figure 4.1: FAO’s program spending projection is lower than the government’s through 2024-25

Source: FAO analysis of the 2022 Ontario Economic Outlook and Fiscal Review and information provided by the Ministry of Finance.

Accessible version

Despite excess funds, government spending plan includes shortfalls in some sectors

Although the FAO projects that the Province has allocated $12.5 billion in excess funds to support existing programs and announced commitments over the three-year period, differences arise by program sector. The FAO projects spending shortfalls in health (net $5.0 billion over three years), education ($1.1 billion), justice ($0.8 billion) and postsecondary education ($0.4 billion). These shortfalls mean that the Province has not allocated sufficient funds to these sectors to support existing programs and announced commitments over the three-year period.

On the other hand, the Province has allocated excess funds to ‘other programs’ (net $19.7 billion over three years) and children’s and social services ($0.2 billion). The significant excess funds in the other programs sector are largely due to the contingency fund.[10] Contingency funds are typically used to support existing programs with funding shortfalls, fund new programs or enhance existing programs. Alternatively, if the Province decides not to use the contingency funds, then these funds are applied to improve the budget balance and reduce the Province’s net debt.

For the five main sectors combined, the FAO projects a total funding shortfall of $7.2 billion over three years, which is an improvement of $2.5 billion from the $9.7 billion projected shortfall as of the FAO’s Fall EBO. The decrease in the shortfall is due mainly to the government allocating an additional $2.2 billion in funding to these sectors as part of the FES,[11] largely from the contingency fund. This new funding went to children’s and social services ($1,460 million, primarily for enhancements to the Ontario Disability Support Program[12]), education ($376 million, for the Catch Up Payments program[13]), health ($278 million) and postsecondary education ($94 million).

5. Economic Outlook

Global economic outlook remains weak

The global economy grew by an estimated 3.2 per cent in 2022, moderating from 6.0 per cent growth in 2021, as broad and persistent inflation, economic damage from the war in Ukraine, and COVID-19-related lockdowns in China created significant challenges.

With inflation likely remaining above the target of most central banks for much of 2023, interest rates are expected to be high throughout the year. As a result, both the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) expect global economic growth to slow further in 2023, with notable weakness in advanced economies.[14]

By 2024, a mild recovery in economic activity is projected in most countries as demand and supply imbalances fade and inflation slows. However, the end of China’s zero-COVID policy could help alleviate supply chain challenges, lower global inflationary pressures through improved product availability, and boost economic growth by more than anticipated. Other factors such as larger-than-expected negative impacts from higher interest rates and heightened geopolitical tensions particularly in Ukraine could stifle global economic growth during the next couple of years.

Figure 5.1: Global economic outlook for 2023 remains weak

Source: International Monetary Fund.

Accessible version

Ontario outlook: elevated inflation and high interest rates to slow economic growth sharply

Ontario’s average annual inflation rate reached a 40-year high of 6.8 per cent in 2022, led by a 22.9 per cent increase in energy prices and a 9.1 per cent increase in food prices. Although supply chain challenges have eased somewhat, inflation is expected to stay above historical averages[15] in 2023 and moderate gradually as lower global commodity costs begin to affect consumer prices. By 2024, inflation is expected to settle close to two per cent as the economy fully adjusts to higher interest rates.

Figure 5.2: Inflation projected to moderate gradually over the next two years

Source: Statistics Canada and FAO.

Accessible version

In response to elevated inflation, the Bank of Canada aggressively raised its policy interest rate from 0.25 per cent in March 2022 to 4.50 per cent in January 2023, the highest in 16 years. With economic growth and inflation slowing, the FAO expects the Bank of Canada will keep its policy interest rate at 4.50 per cent for much of 2023.

In line with most private sector economists, the FAO projects that short-term interest rates will stay above long-term rates in 2023, which has historically indicated the possibility of weak economic growth. As inflation eases closer to the Bank’s two per cent target, short-term interest rates are projected to fall below long-term rates in 2024.

Figure 5.3: Short-term interest rates to remain high in 2023 and 2024

Source: Statistics Canada and FAO.

Accessible version

Ontario’s Real GDP growth projected to slow sharply in 2023

Ontario’s real GDP expanded by an estimated 3.7 per cent in 2022, moderating from 5.2 per cent growth in 2021, as high inflation, rising interest rates and the weaker global environment dampened the economic recovery from the pandemic.

The pace of Ontario’s economic growth is projected to slow sharply to 0.5 per cent in 2023, reflecting the impact of higher interest rates on household spending and the weakening housing market. A rebound in auto sector production and exports may boost Ontario’s economic growth but will depend on supply chain improvements and the health of consumer demand in Canada and the United States.

While the FAO is currently projecting a significant slowdown for Ontario’s economy in 2023, certain risks to the outlook could result in a slower or faster pace of economic growth. See discussion in Chapter 6.

Figure 5.4: Ontario’s economic growth to slow sharply in 2023

Source: Ontario Economic Accounts and FAO.

Accessible version

Ontario’s job market expected to slow

Ontario recorded another year of strong employment growth in 2022, pushing the annual unemployment rate down to 5.6 per cent, which matches the rate prior to the pandemic and is one of the lowest on record.

As the economy slows, job growth in 2023 is expected to weaken, with employment rising by 0.5 per cent. The unemployment rate is projected to rise to 6.4 per cent in 2023 as employers slow their pace of hiring and layoffs increase. In 2024, the unemployment rate is projected to stay at 6.4 per cent, with stronger job gains offset by solid growth in the labour force. Over the remainder of the outlook, the unemployment rate is projected to average 6.2 per cent.

Figure 5.5: Unemployment rate expected to rise in 2023

Source: Statistics Canada and FAO.

Accessible version

Ontario’s nominal GDP growth to moderate

Ontario’s nominal GDP, which provides a broad measure of the tax base, extended its strong post-pandemic performance in 2022, rising by an estimated 9.6 per cent due to the acceleration in economy-wide prices.

Following two years of exceptional growth, Ontario’s nominal GDP growth is projected to moderate in 2023 to 3.5 per cent. Labour income growth is expected to soften as employers cut back on hiring and wage expense, while corporate profit growth is projected to slow sharply as consumer spending cools.

Over the 2024 to 2026 period, nominal GDP is expected to grow at an average annual rate of 3.7 per cent.

Figure 5.6: Ontario’s nominal GDP growth to moderate in 2023

Source: Ontario Economic Accounts and FAO.

Accessible version

6. Risks to the Economic and Budget Outlook

Economic and budget uncertainties

Ontario’s economic growth has been resilient since the initial pandemic restrictions were lifted, but several domestic and global factors pose downside risks to the outlook. High inflation could persist, further eroding household purchasing power as savings decline. The impact of higher interest rates on the housing market could be more severe than expected as mortgage payments of many highly indebted households are reset to much larger amounts. If the Federal Reserve follows through on its intent to continue raising interest rates and the U.S. economy experiences a recession, this would create a larger setback to Ontario’s exports of intermediate and manufactured goods. Russia’s war in Ukraine and geopolitical tensions could further disrupt global markets and add to inflationary pressures.

On the upside, the loosening of pandemic lockdown measures in China could further reduce supply chain bottlenecks, lower global inflationary pressures through improved product availability, and provide a boost to economic growth. Fiscal policy targeted to combat the cost-of-living challenge in many countries including Canada, combined with high savings, could help mitigate cost pressures facing households. Some central banks have signalled that they are scaling back the pace of rate hikes, and if inflation continues to slow, expectations for a pause or a decline in interest rates would improve confidence in the economy. Sharply lower energy costs, notably for natural gas, could lessen the expected slowdown in European economic growth.

Ontario’s budget outlook is subject to the same risks affecting the economic outlook, in addition to various other uncertainties. The following notable risks to the budget outlook could result in a deterioration of the Province’s finances:

• Wage settlements above the historical average. The FAO’s program spending forecast assumes wage growth is consistent with existing collective agreements and, for new collective agreements, historical long-term average growth in wages. However, given the forecast for elevated inflation, potential exists for above-average wage settlements.[16] Under an inflation scenario recently developed by the FAO, elevated inflation could add $6.8 billion in additional provincial spending on wages over the five-year forecast period to 2026-27.[17]
• The legal challenge to Bill 124.[18] On November 29, 2022, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice ruled that Bill 124, which limits base salary increases for most provincial employees to one per cent per year for a period of three years, was in violation of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and was declared to be void and of no effect. The government has appealed this decision. If the government is unsuccessful in its appeal, then the FAO estimates that provincial spending on wages could increase by $8.4 billion over the five-year period to 2026-27.[19]
• Future policy announcements, such as new tax cuts, spending initiatives or a combination of both.

Increased transfer revenue could also impact Ontario's budget outlook as health care agreements between the federal government and the provinces and territories are finalized.

Budget sensitivities

To illustrate the impact of potential policy changes on Ontario’s fiscal projection, the FAO estimated the sensitivity of key budget indicators to changes in three main policy areas: tax revenues, federal transfers and program expenditures. For each policy item, Table 6-1 provides an estimate of the in-year and 2026-27 change in the budget balance, the total change in net debt by 2026-27, and the change in the net debt-to-GDP ratio in 2026-27.

7. Appendix

About this document

Established by the Financial Accountability Officer Act, 2013, the Financial Accountability Office (FAO) provides independent analysis on the state of the Province’s finances, trends in the provincial economy and related matters important to the Legislative Assembly of Ontario.

This report was prepared by Sabrina Afroz, Zohra Jamasi, Jay Park, Nicolas Rhodes and Matthew Stephenson, under the direction of Paul Lewis, Edward Crummey, Luan Ngo and Jeffrey Novak. Eklavya Jain, Michelle Gordon, Matthew Gurnham, Jacob Kim and Ben Segel-Brown contributed to this report.

The content of this report is based on information available to January 25, 2023. Background data used in this report are available upon request.

In keeping with the FAO’s mandate to provide the Legislative Assembly of Ontario with independent economic and financial analysis, this report makes no policy recommendations.

Graphical Descriptions

Footnotes